The Hate U Give

First Hit: A fantastic film about the existence of racism and, as indicated here, in our police departments as well.

I’ve seen three films this year that deal directly with racism, Blindspotting, BlacKkKlansman, and this film The Hate U Give. In both Blindspotting and this film, we have a white policeman shooting and killing an unarmed black man.

The film starts with Maverick “Mav” Carter (Russell Hornsby) giving his children; Starr (Amandla Stenberg), Seven (Lamar Johnson), and Sekani (TJ Wright), “the talk.” Mav’s been to prison, he’s fought the hard life but wants to stop the cycle of violence and pain in the family.

He's giving his children the talk about how to act when they are stopped by police for any reason because he knows how they will be viewed being black.

I was deeply saddened listening to this because it’s 2018 and I don't understand why haven't figured out that racism, in any form, is wrong. It shows that we’ve barely grown as a country.

Their mother, Lisa (Regina Hall), doesn’t want them exposed to the school in their ghetto neighborhood so she sends them to a mostly white college prep school. She wants her children to not be unduly influenced.

Before long, it happens. Starr is being driven home with her lifelong friend Khalil (Algee Smith), when they are stopped for changing lanes without signaling. Khalil, despite Starr’s insistence that he follow the cop’s commands, mouths off to the officer and eventually follows the officer’s commands. Standing outside the car, facing the car, while the policeman checks his ID, Khalil reaches in the car to get a hairbrush, and the officer shoots and kills him. Starr witnesses the whole thing and is in shock.

Starr testifies in front of the Grand Jury, the jury decides to not indict the officer, and the city goes into an uproar. Sound familiar? Yes, this scene has been happening across the U.S., and even with incriminating video footage we’re not holding policeman responsible for their quick trigger behavior.

This film explores this issue when Starr asks her uncle Carlos (Common), who is a black police officer, why police act this way. When he starts his monologue about how a policeman has to act and respond to tense situations, I found myself thinking, wow this is a compelling argument and I can nearly see why a policeman would react this way. However, when Starr asks would the cop shoot a white guy dressed in a suit driving a Mercedes, or would he ask the white guy to put his hands up. Carlos pauses, then says, he’d tell the white guy to put his hands up.

This is the issue. Why would a black police officer shoot the black man but tell the well dressed white man to raise his hands.

Other race issues show up when Starr’s closest friend at her prep school, Hailey (Sabrina Carpenter) shows her true colors as Starr becomes more vocal about her community in her community. A great juxtaposition was her white boyfriend Chris (K.J. Apa) who supports Starr in her quest to be seen and speak her truth. My only criticism of this film is that there are sections that seemed elongated or unnecessary that altered the intense pacing of this film. I would have rather had some smart trimming to keep the pacing at the higher level.

Regardless, this film has things to say and in summary, we’ve got a lot to learn and it starts with each of us doing soul searching.

Stenberg was sublime as Starr. She was both verbally and visually expressive at the right moments. Hall was wonderful as the strong mother who wants the best for her children but also gives them enough reign to grow. Hornsby was fantastic as the father. His pent up and controlled rage channeled to help his family was perfectly expressed in this film. Common was strong and his discussion with Starr about “what if…” was key. Apa was extraordinary in his role as the white boyfriend. Johnson and Wright were amazing as Starr’s siblings. Hall was wonderfully charismatic and excellent as the young man killed by the white officer. Anthony Mackie was very strong as King, the neighborhood drug dealer, controlling the actions of many. Audrey Wells wrote a strong script. George Tillman Jr. did a wonderful job directing this story and strong actors keeping the point of racism in focus.

Overall: This was an emotional film to watch as witnessed by the numerous times I had to wipe my eyes.

Detroit

First Hit:  Extremely powerful film about racial injustice in the city of Detroit in 1967.

Kathryn Bigelow has a history of taking on difficult powerful subjects and bringing them to life. She is a master director. Her filmography continues to get stronger and stronger. From her Blue Steel and Point Break days to The Hurt Locker, Zero Dark Thirty and now, Detroit.

I feel fortunate that, once again, in the matter of a few short weeks I’ve been able to see films where the focus is the story and not particular characters. And what makes this film even better is that although it takes place in 1967 it reflects the targeting of blacks today by law enforcement.

To do this Bigelow seamlessly incorporates actual 1967 film footage and stills into her vision of this story. We follow several black characters who end up being innocently targeted by law enforcement for being at a particular place, at a particular time, and because of the color of their skin.

The script was developed from court transcripts and proceedings, interviews of some survivors and an honest interpretation by the writer. The focus is the murder of three black men and the beatings of seven other black men and two white women by the Detroit Police Department and tacitly condoned by US National Guard. This incident took place at the Algiers Motel, in Detroit during the 12th Street Riots. They victims had gone to the hotel to hide out and stay off the streets because there was a curfew and people couldn’t get home.

One of the guests at the motel shoots a toy pistol, which is mistaken by the police and National Guard as sniper fire. In rushing the motel’s building the police drag these motel guests down to the bottom floor and begin interrogating them to discover where the gun was and who shot the gun. Despite killing the person who shot the never found toy gun, the police used extreme tactics to scare the other guests. They systematically pulled people into rooms threatening to shoot them if they didn't have answers to their questions. They also mercilessly beat each person.

In doing so, they killed another two. For hours they continued to beat each of the suspects to get them to talk. Finally, the police decided they need to leave. To cover their tracks, they threaten each of the remaining suspects, that if they were ever to speak of this event again, they will die.

Eventually, this event and the officers are brought to trial and the all-white jury exonerates the three guilty police officers. Sound familiar?

John Boyega (as Dismukes) is amazing as the black private security officer that attempts to be the peacemaker and mediator between the cops and guests. Boyega is great at hinting, what appears to be, regret that he didn’t do more to help his fellow brothers. Will Poulter (as Officer Krauss) did a wonderful job being everyone’s nightmare. It was not an enviable role but as the racist officer he made the hate real. Algee Smith and Jacob Latimore (as friends and bandmates Larry and Fred respectively) were fantastic as their dreams were taken from them that night. Hannah Murray and Kaitlyn Dever (as Julie and Karen respectively were the beaten white women) were wonderful. They really made their roles standout with honesty. Anthony Mackie as Greene the Vietnam vet who got caught up in the motel was perfect. Mark Boal wrote a fantastic Oscar worthy script. Bigelow, as I previously said, is clearly one of the strongest directors of our time. Her clarity of vision and storytelling is amazing.

Overall:  I recall reading and seeing television news stories about these events when they happened, but only until I saw this film, did I understand the horror.